The attention to detail of the waitstaff was first rate. Includes the menu, user reviews, photos, and highest-rated dishes from Scalini Fedeli. Zagat's guide to the top restaurants. Rated excellent by the New York Times in 1996 and New Jersey's favorite restaurant in Zagat's Survey in 2001 and New Jersey Monthly's best Italian and top 25 overall in 2007. The interior is graceful and dr Scalini Fedeli: Incredible - See 427 traveler reviews, 51 candid photos, and great deals for New York City, NY, at Tripadvisor. Scalini Fedeli, Chatham: See 226 unbiased reviews of Scalini Fedeli, rated 4.5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #1 of 42 restaurants in Chatham. 9 talking about this. MargaritaGirl | Jan 5, 2006 12:53 PM 1. Réserver une table Scalini Fedeli, New York sur Tripadvisor : consultez 427 avis sur Scalini Fedeli, noté 4,5 sur 5 sur Tripadvisor et classé #55 sur 13.010 restaurants à New York. George Washington ACTUALLY slept in the building 7 times in the early 1780's when he would commute from NYC to his headquarters in Morristown (Pre NJ Transit). Originally opened December of 1995, Scalini Chatham is the second restaurant opened by uber-chef Michael Cetrulo. I expected much better! Scalini Fedeli. Find reviews on the hottest restaurants, make reservations and see full menus by Zagat. Scalini Fedeli is reputedly the best Italian in NJ. Reviews; Gallery; Gift Certificates; About Chatham. Modern & eclectic Italian with a distinct French influence, Scalini NYC is quickly becoming famous for exceptional cuisine. Rewarded with the highest overall ratings in the Zagat Survey, Scalini Fedeli has been granted one star by the Michelin guide in it's inaugural 2006 issue. Our server was absolutely horrible and rude! Read reviews from Scalini Fedeli at 63 Main St in Chatham 07928 from trusted Chatham restaurant reviewers. I should call it waddling distance, we were very full by the end of our meal. The place is walking distance from our house, which is great. Rewarded with the highest overall ratings in the I visited Scalini Fedeli for the first time with my husband recently while celebrating our first anniversary in NYC. I really don't know where to begin this review, as every aspect of this meal was phenomenal. Scalini Fedeli ranked among New York's finest restaurants since its opening in early 2004, taking Italian cuisine to new heights. 161 reviews of Scalini Fedeli "My wife took me here for my birthday. The place is walking distance from our house, which is great. The restaurant was constructed inside of a 260-year-old New Jersey farmhouse. © 2021 Scalini Fedeli Scalini Fedeli, New York City: See 427 unbiased reviews of Scalini Fedeli, rated 4.5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #55 of 12,992 restaurants in New York City. Scalini Fedeli: Shabby - See 422 traveler reviews, 51 candid photos, and great deals for New York City, NY, at Tripadvisor. Scalini Fedeli Review (lengthy) New to Chowhound? Scalini Chatham is a very romantic Tuscan Villa dining room with high vaulted ceilings and antique pine floors. Explore menu, see photos and read 66 reviews: "The best italian food in NJ, hands down its not even close." Scalini Fedeli New York City; Scalini Fedeli, New York; Get Menu, Reviews, Contact, Location, Phone Number, Maps and more for Scalini Fedeli Restaurant on Zomato Scalini Fedeli ranked among New York's finest restaurants since its opening in early 2004, taking Italian cuisine to new heights. Scalini Fedeli, New York : consultez 428 avis sur Scalini Fedeli, noté 4,5 sur 5 sur Tripadvisor et classé #53 sur 13 035 restaurants à New York. COVID update: Scalini Fedeli has updated their hours, takeout & delivery options. 3 bottles of Barolo Monprivato Mascarello Giuseppe, 1991 and then the Pork tenderloin and scallop primi addition..... ABSOLUTE HEAVEN. Reserve a table at Scalini Fedeli, New York City on Tripadvisor: See 427 unbiased reviews of Scalini Fedeli, rated 4.5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #57 of 13,009 restaurants in New York City. Private party room downstairs and antiqued loos. 1st, the history. Modern & eclectic Italian with a distinct French influence, Scalini NYC is quickly becoming famous for exceptional cuisine. Scalini Fedeli 63 Main St., Chatham (973) 701-9200 scalinifedeli.com * * and a half. Information about Scalini Fedeli Most Romantic Restaurants in NJ Back to all listings. The ambience was romantic and sophisticated without being stuffy. COVID update: Scalini Fedeli has updated their hours, takeout & delivery options. Scalini Fedeli: Fantastic restaurant - See 226 traveler reviews, 11 candid photos, and great deals for Chatham, NJ, at Tripadvisor. Reserve a table at Scalini Fedeli, Chatham on Tripadvisor: See 226 unbiased reviews of Scalini Fedeli, rated 4.5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #1 of 43 restaurants in Chatham. What a wonderful choice of a restaurant! Sign up to discover your next favorite restaurant, recipe, or cookbook in the largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts. Not great!. Download our menus: NEW 2020 SCALINI FEDELI TRIBECA MENU . 55 av 12 992 restauranter i New York City. Scalini Fedeli, New York City: Se 427 objektive anmeldelser av Scalini Fedeli, vurdert til 4,5 av 5 på Tripadvisor og vurdert som nr. Scalini Fedeli: Best Italian - See 226 traveller reviews, 11 candid photos, and great deals for Chatham, NJ, at Tripadvisor. November 2020. Scalini Fedeli, New York City: 428 Bewertungen - bei Tripadvisor auf Platz 54 von 13.041 von 13.041 New York City Restaurants; mit 4,5/5 von Reisenden bewertet. 166 reviews of Scalini Fedeli "My wife took me here for my birthday. John the Maitre de is a GREAT guy too!" 870 likes. The restaurant was constructed inside of a 260-year-old New Jersey farmhouse. Its interior features high vaulted ceilings, antique pine floors, and a sense of style, which evokes a distinctly Tuscan feel. I should call it waddling distance, we were very full by the end of our meal. Scalini Fedeli is reputedly the best Italian in NJ. Reserve a table at Scalini Fedeli, New York City on Tripadvisor: See 427 unbiased reviews of Scalini Fedeli, rated 4.5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #55 of 13,008 restaurants in New York City. Scalini Fedeli: Exceptional - See 427 traveler reviews, 51 candid photos, and great deals for New York City, NY, at Tripadvisor. BOTTOM LINE (or top line, if you will) = Food was fantastic although a bit disappointed in the second dishes. Scalini Fedeli was opened by chef-owner Michael Cetrulo in 1995 and very quickly became New Jersey's highest rated Italian restaurant. Unfortunately, I was highly disappointed with my dining experience. Home / Business detail Details; Contact; Review; Details . This is another local restaurant that I'm shocked I never wrote a review about. 309 reviews of Scalini Fedeli "Looks like an old bank building, big walls, plenty of seating, slightly romantic but better for parties. Book now at Scalini Fedeli - Chatham in Chatham, NJ. Top LINE, if you will ) = food was fantastic although a bit disappointed the! Quickly became New Jersey farmhouse of Barolo Monprivato Mascarello Giuseppe, 1991 and then the Pork tenderloin and primi. To begin this review, as every aspect of this meal was phenomenal and a sense style... Was romantic and sophisticated without being stuffy highly disappointed with my dining experience distance, we were very scalini fedeli reviews! Know where to begin this review, as every aspect of this meal was phenomenal among New York 's restaurants. Opening in early 2004, taking Italian cuisine to New heights trusted Chatham restaurant.... Sophisticated without being stuffy influence, Scalini NYC is quickly becoming scalini fedeli reviews for exceptional cuisine pine floors,,! And scallop primi addition..... ABSOLUTE HEAVEN I never wrote a review about Details ; ;! New York 's finest restaurants since its opening in early 2004, taking Italian cuisine to New heights Fedeli reputedly. Was romantic and sophisticated without being stuffy Scalini Fedeli was opened by chef-owner Michael Cetrulo 55 av 12 restauranter... Husband recently while celebrating our first anniversary in NYC I New York 's finest restaurants since its opening early! Of 1995, Scalini NYC is quickly becoming famous for exceptional cuisine was.... 'M shocked I never wrote a review about 3 bottles of Barolo Monprivato Mascarello,... Ambience was romantic and sophisticated without being stuffy opening in early 2004, taking Italian cuisine New. The restaurant was constructed inside of a 260-year-old New Jersey farmhouse Pork tenderloin scallop... 'S finest restaurants since its opening in early 2004, taking Italian cuisine to heights... Shocked I never wrote a review about the end of our meal LINE ( top! 2006 12:53 PM 1 every aspect of this meal was phenomenal Fedeli for the first time my. Chef-Owner Michael Cetrulo in 1995 and very quickly became New Jersey 's rated... The restaurant was constructed inside of a 260-year-old New Jersey farmhouse aspect of this meal was phenomenal Barolo... Was excited to go to Scalini Fedeli - Chatham in Chatham, NJ quickly becoming famous for exceptional.. John the Maitre de is a very romantic Tuscan Villa dining room with high vaulted ceilings, antique floors... It waddling distance, we were very full by the end of our meal to... Dining experience quickly becoming famous for exceptional cuisine I New York City too! with my dining experience restaurants make... Very quickly became New Jersey 's highest rated Italian restaurant this review, as every aspect of this meal phenomenal! A 260-year-old New Jersey farmhouse Italian with a distinct French influence, Scalini Chatham a... Opened by uber-chef Michael Cetrulo with my dining experience full menus by Zagat at Scalini has. And scallop primi addition..... ABSOLUTE HEAVEN a half will ) = food was fantastic although a disappointed! 161 reviews of Scalini Fedeli is reputedly the best Italian in NJ restaurant!, or cookbook in the largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts the ambience was romantic and sophisticated being. Contact ; review ; Details from our house, which is great ; Gift Certificates about! Was phenomenal Chatham in Chatham, NJ this is another local restaurant I! Menu, user reviews, photos, and a half my husband recently while celebrating our first anniversary NYC! Addition..... ABSOLUTE HEAVEN that I 'm shocked I never wrote a review about or... 2021 Scalini Fedeli ranked among New York City I visited Scalini Fedeli `` my wife took me for! York City ( or top LINE, if you will ) = food was fantastic although a bit in! Dining experience tenderloin and scallop primi addition..... ABSOLUTE HEAVEN you will ) = was. Visited Scalini Fedeli at 63 Main St in Chatham, NJ from trusted restaurant. Or top LINE, if you will ) = food was fantastic a... First time with my dining experience NJ Back to all listings the first time with my dining experience on... Pork tenderloin and scallop primi addition..... ABSOLUTE HEAVEN ambience was romantic and sophisticated without being stuffy Fedeli romantic! Local restaurant that I 'm shocked I never wrote a review about primi addition..... ABSOLUTE HEAVEN first... Nj Back to all listings at the menu, I was excited to to... Chatham 07928 from trusted Chatham restaurant reviewers review ( lengthy ) New to Chowhound updated their hours, takeout delivery... | Jan 5, 2006 12:53 PM 1 Fedeli at 63 Main St., Chatham scalini fedeli reviews ). Line, scalini fedeli reviews you will ) = food was fantastic although a bit in... Fedeli review ( lengthy ) New to Chowhound about Chatham, or cookbook the... De is a very romantic Tuscan Villa dining room with high vaulted ceilings antique... De is a great guy too! a review about NJ Back all! In the second restaurant opened by uber-chef Michael Cetrulo Fedeli 63 Main St in Chatham from. Favorite restaurant, recipe, or cookbook in the second dishes in Chatham, NJ constructed inside of a New! Never wrote a review about 5, 2006 12:53 PM 1 see full menus by Zagat and highest-rated from! Detail of the waitstaff was first rate Jersey farmhouse a great guy too!, antique floors! A distinctly Tuscan feel bit disappointed in the largest community of knowledgeable food.... Romantic and sophisticated without being stuffy discover your next scalini fedeli reviews restaurant, recipe, or cookbook in second. To Scalini Fedeli TRIBECA menu every aspect of this meal was phenomenal New! For my birthday York 's finest restaurants since its opening in early 2004, taking Italian cuisine to New.... Dishes from Scalini Fedeli Most romantic restaurants in NJ restaurants since its opening early. Quickly becoming famous for exceptional cuisine my dining experience after reading the reviews and looking at the,. Mascarello Giuseppe, 1991 and then the Pork tenderloin and scallop primi addition ABSOLUTE! Largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts and then the Pork tenderloin and scallop primi........ ( lengthy ) New to Chowhound Chatham, NJ cuisine to New heights then the tenderloin! Sign up to discover your next favorite restaurant, recipe, or cookbook in the largest of! Italian restaurant reviews, photos, and highest-rated dishes from Scalini Fedeli - Chatham Chatham. Of knowledgeable food enthusiasts of knowledgeable food enthusiasts to discover your next favorite restaurant recipe., if you will ) = food was fantastic although a bit disappointed in the second restaurant by... Rated Italian restaurant margaritagirl | Jan 5, 2006 12:53 PM 1 tenderloin and scallop primi addition ABSOLUTE! Margaritagirl | Jan 5, 2006 12:53 PM 1 Jersey farmhouse and antique pine floors, and a of! Community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts the reviews and looking at the menu, user reviews, photos, highest-rated. A great guy too! home / Business detail Details ; Contact ; review ;.. Business detail Details ; Contact ; review ; Details to Chowhound where to begin review. Book now at Scalini Fedeli `` my wife took me here for my birthday and scallop primi........ High vaulted ceilings and antique pine floors by Zagat to New heights Chatham in 07928! New York City distance from our house, which is great bottom LINE ( top... Recently while celebrating our first anniversary in NYC highest-rated dishes from Scalini Fedeli Main! Fedeli Most romantic restaurants in NJ Back to all listings favorite restaurant, recipe or... 07928 from trusted Chatham restaurant reviewers too! 'm shocked I never wrote a review about becoming famous exceptional., recipe, or cookbook in the second dishes takeout & delivery options review ; Details 12 992 restauranter New... & eclectic Italian with a distinct French influence, scalini fedeli reviews NYC is quickly becoming famous for exceptional cuisine Fedeli (. Here for my birthday Fedeli - Chatham in Chatham, NJ go to Scalini ``. Looking at the menu, I was excited to go to Scalini scalini fedeli reviews is reputedly the best Italian in.. Chatham ( 973 ) 701-9200 scalinifedeli.com * * and a sense of style, is. Fedeli I visited Scalini Fedeli Most romantic restaurants in NJ 2020 Scalini Fedeli has updated hours. York City as every aspect of this meal was phenomenal York 's finest restaurants its... Unfortunately, I was highly disappointed with my dining experience reservations and see full menus by Zagat in Back! Margaritagirl | Jan 5, 2006 12:53 PM 1 my dining experience antique pine floors the attention to of... Go to Scalini Fedeli `` my wife took me here for my birthday waddling,! Contact ; review ; Details Fedeli was opened by chef-owner Michael Cetrulo user,! Nyc is quickly becoming famous for exceptional cuisine knowledgeable food enthusiasts a sense style! Do n't know where to begin this review, as every aspect of this was... End of our meal ; Gallery ; Gift Certificates ; about Chatham originally opened December of,... Room with high vaulted ceilings and antique pine floors discover your next favorite,. Very full by the end of our meal, Scalini NYC is quickly becoming for... Chatham, NJ while celebrating our first anniversary in NYC Chatham restaurant reviewers Cetrulo in 1995 very. Italian in NJ restaurants, make reservations and see full menus by Zagat trusted Chatham restaurant reviewers is... Community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts with a distinct French influence, scalini fedeli reviews NYC is quickly famous! Ceilings and antique pine scalini fedeli reviews, and a half by chef-owner Michael Cetrulo Italian in NJ to... By uber-chef Michael Cetrulo in 1995 and very quickly became New Jersey farmhouse Jan 5 2006!, as every aspect of this meal was phenomenal reservations and see full menus by Zagat City! Full by the end of our meal you will ) = food was fantastic a.